For Macy’s bedding, these three sets serve different priorities: the Madison Park Signature Cotton Clip Jacquard Comforter Set stands out for a dressed-up bed and its removable cover, the Laura Ashley Bedford Quilt Set is the lighter, simpler choice for layering, and the Laura Ashley Mattie Stripe Serenity Roses Comforter Set gives you a washable floral look with coordinating accents. I rank them by how well each set matches a clear bedding need, not by treating a larger piece count as an automatic win.
Get furniture and decor delivered free with Prime
- Fast, free delivery on millions of items
- Prime Video, Amazon Music and more included
- Member-only deals all year
The main choice is between coverage and decoration, light layering, and easy-care comforter styling. Madison Park includes the most pieces, but its cover is dry clean only. Bedford is easier to care for and lighter, but offers less warmth and fewer styling extras. Mattie brings the most practical balance for shoppers who want a cotton-faced comforter and decorative pieces without a dry-clean-only cover, though its polyester fill and gentle-cycle instructions are tradeoffs. I’ve focused this guide on what those differences mean for everyday bedroom use.
Complete the kit
Key Takeaways
- Choose Madison Park for oversized queen coverage, cotton fabric on both sides, and a removable duvet-style cover; plan for dry cleaning the cover.
- Choose Laura Ashley Bedford for a lightweight, reversible cotton quilt that is machine washable and suited to layering rather than heavy warmth.
- Choose Laura Ashley Mattie for a machine-washable comforter set with a cotton face and reverse plus coordinated floral and stripe details.
- Set contents differ substantially: Madison Park includes seven decorative and bed-cover pieces beyond the comforter, Bedford includes two standard shams, and Mattie includes pillowcases, a Euro sham, and two throw pillow covers.
- Check dimensions and care before choosing: the queen comforters are not the same size, and Mattie’s gentle wash and low-heat drying instructions are more specific than Bedford’s machine-washable care.
| Madison Park Signature Queen Cotton Clip Jacquard Comforter Set, Ivory, 8-Piece | ![]() | Best Overall for an Oversized, Layered Bed | Size: Queen | Color: Ivory | Comforter dimensions: 92 x 96 inches | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Laura Ashley Bedford Blue Reversible Cotton Quilt Set, Queen, 3-Piece | ![]() | Best Lightweight Quilt for Layering | Size: Queen | Color and pattern: Blue and white floral toile with geometric reverse | Quilt dimensions: 90 x 90 inches | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Laura Ashley Mattie Stripe Serenity Roses Reversible Comforter Set, Full/Queen, 7-Piece | ![]() | Best Washable Comforter for a Coordinated Floral Look | Set size: Full/Queen, 7 pieces | Comforter dimensions: 88 x 92 inches | Design: Reversible roses and stripe pattern | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Macy’s bedding | Care | Size | Comforter dimensions | Set contents |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Madison Park Signature Queen C | Dry clean cover; machine wash insert | Queen | 92 x 96 inches | Comforter, 2 standard shams, 2 Euro shams, 3 decorative pillows |
| Laura Ashley Bedford Blue Reve | Machine washable | Queen | — | 1 quilt and 2 standard shams |
| Laura Ashley Mattie Stripe Ser | Machine wash cold on gentle; tumble dry low | — | 88 x 92 inches | — |
More Details on Our Top Picks
Madison Park Signature Queen Cotton Clip Jacquard Comforter Set, Ivory, 8-Piece
I rank this Madison Park set first because it brings together the broadest mix of cotton comforter fabric, generous coverage, and coordinated styling. The 92-by-96-inch comforter is larger than the listed 90-by-90-inch Bedford quilt and 88-by-92-inch Mattie comforter, which may appeal to queen-bed owners who want more fabric over the sides. Its clipped jacquard stripes and decorative buttons also create more texture than Bedford’s printed quilt pattern, while the ivory palette is easier to pair with changing accent colors than Mattie’s pink rose design.
The removable, duvet-style cover is its most distinctive practical feature. Inner ties and a hidden button closure help keep the insert in place, and taking the cover off may make seasonal changes easier than washing a complete comforter. The insert is machine washable, but the cover requires dry cleaning, so this is not the low-maintenance winner. Bedford is the clearer pick if simple machine washing matters most; Mattie is more convenient for home laundering, though its instructions call for a gentle cycle and low heat.
The eight-piece presentation suits someone who wants the bed to look finished without sourcing separate shams and accent pillows. The set includes two standard shams, two Euro shams, and three decorative pillows in addition to the comforter. That fullness comes with a materials caveat: the decorative pillow covers include different fabrics, including acrylic and cotton, rather than matching the comforter’s all-cotton face and back. I’d choose this set for a layered guest room or a bedroom where a complete coordinated look matters more than minimal upkeep. I’d skip it if dry cleaning is a dealbreaker or if a simple, lightweight cover is the goal.
Pros:- Oversized 92-by-96-inch comforter offers more coverage than the other two listed options.
- 100% cotton face and back provide a natural-fiber surface.
- Removable cover has inner ties and a hidden button closure.
- Includes two standard shams, two Euro shams, and three decorative pillows.
Cons:- The removable cover requires dry cleaning, even though the insert is machine washable.
- Decorative pillow covers use mixed materials, including acrylic and cotton.
- The 19.6-pound listed item weight and full set may feel cumbersome to handle or store.
Best for: Queen-bed shoppers who want generous coverage, cotton fabric on both sides of the comforter, and a coordinated set with several pillows and shams.
Not ideal for: Anyone who wants every bedding component to be machine washable, prefers a lighter quilt, or wants all included pillow covers made from one fabric.
- Size:Queen
- Color:Ivory
- Comforter dimensions:92 x 96 inches
- Comforter fabric:100% cotton face and back
- Filling:Hypoallergenic polyester down alternative
- Set contents:Comforter, 2 standard shams, 2 Euro shams, 3 decorative pillows
- Cover details:Removable; hidden button closure and inner ties
- Care:Dry clean cover; machine wash insert
Our verdict“I’d choose Madison Park for the most complete, generously sized bed presentation, provided dry cleaning the cover fits your care routine.”
Laura Ashley Bedford Blue Reversible Cotton Quilt Set, Queen, 3-Piece
Bedford is the most straightforward choice here when you want a lightweight, reversible quilt rather than a lofty comforter. Its blue floral toile print flips to a coordinating geometric pattern, giving the bed two looks without adding separate bedding. Compared with Madison Park’s textured jacquard and large pillow assortment, Bedford feels more restrained: one quilt and two standard shams keep the set focused, while the reversible design supplies the visual variety.
The 100% cotton shell and cotton-rich fill support its role as a layer you can use across the year, depending on room temperature and what goes underneath. The quilt weighs 4.8 pounds and measures 90 by 90 inches, making it a noticeably lighter, less bulky option than Madison Park’s comforter set. That convenience is also its main limitation: light fill is not a substitute for substantial warmth. If you want a plush, enveloping bed, Madison Park or Mattie is a better match. If you already have blankets and need a decorative top layer, Bedford is the more sensible fit.
Care is a strong point in this comparison. Bedford is machine washable and pre-washed for softness, unlike Madison Park’s dry-clean-only cover. Its 136 thread count is listed, but I would put more weight on the quilt’s breathable shell, manageable weight, and reversible styling than on that number alone. The standard shams suit conventional pillows; they may not work for someone whose bed relies on larger or Euro-sized pillows. Choose Bedford for easy seasonal layering and a two-sided pattern. Skip it if your priority is a thick comforter, oversized drape, or a set with decorative pillows and multiple sham sizes.
Pros:- Reversible floral toile and geometric patterns offer two coordinated looks.
- 100% cotton shell with an 80% cotton, 20% polyester fill.
- Lightweight construction suits layering and less bulky bed styling.
- Pre-washed and machine washable for straightforward care.
Cons:- Light fill may not provide enough warmth on its own for colder rooms.
- The 90-by-90-inch quilt is smaller in both listed dimensions than the Madison Park comforter.
- Includes standard shams only, which may not suit larger bed pillows.
Best for: Shoppers who prefer a light, reversible cotton quilt, want machine-washable bedding, and plan to layer for warmth as needed.
Not ideal for: People seeking a heavy or lofty bed covering, extra-deep side coverage, or decorative pillows and Euro shams in the set.
- Size:Queen
- Color and pattern:Blue and white floral toile with geometric reverse
- Quilt dimensions:90 x 90 inches
- Shell:100% cotton
- Fill:80% cotton, 20% polyester
- Set contents:1 quilt and 2 standard shams
- Weight:4.8 pounds
- Care:Machine washable
Our verdict“I’d pick Bedford for an easy-care, lightweight layer, but not as a stand-alone answer for shoppers who want a warm, plush comforter.”
Laura Ashley Mattie Stripe Serenity Roses Reversible Comforter Set, Full/Queen, 7-Piece
Mattie is the pick for shoppers who want the loft of a comforter and the convenience of home washing, without choosing Madison Park’s dry-clean-only cover. Its reversible floral and stripe design gives the bed a softer, more decorative look than Bedford’s blue toile and geometric pairing. The comforter has a 100% cotton face and reverse, while its fill is polyester. That combination gives buyers cotton against the bed surface but not an all-cotton interior; Bedford is the better fit if cotton is also a priority in the fill.
The set includes a full/queen comforter, two standard pillowcases, one Euro sham, and two throw pillow covers. This mix adds more styling pieces than Bedford’s two shams, although it is not the same component assortment as Madison Park’s three decorative pillows and two Euro shams. The listed comforter measures 88 by 92 inches, so it is smaller than Madison Park’s 92-by-96-inch queen comforter. Since the set is labeled full/queen, I’d check those dimensions against the bed and desired overhang instead of assuming it will drape like the larger Madison Park option.
Mattie is machine washable, which makes it a practical alternative to Madison Park for homes that want a comforter set without taking the main cover to a cleaner. It does call for a gentle cold wash and low-heat tumble drying, so care is convenient but not entirely carefree. That is more specific than Bedford’s general machine-washable instruction, and the polyester fill may not suit buyers seeking a natural-fill comforter. I’d select Mattie for its cotton exterior, coordinated accents, and home-laundry approach. I’d pass if you want generous queen coverage, a cotton fill, or the simplest possible wash routine.
Pros:- Reversible floral and stripe styling lets the bed shift between two coordinated looks.
- Comforter face and reverse are 100% cotton.
- Includes standard pillowcases, a Euro sham, and two throw pillow covers.
- Machine washable, with clear care instructions for home laundering.
Cons:- Polyester fill may not suit shoppers seeking an all-cotton comforter.
- At 88 by 92 inches, the comforter is smaller than Madison Park’s listed queen dimensions.
- Requires a gentle cold wash and low-heat tumble drying.
Best for: Full- or queen-bed shoppers who want a reversible floral comforter set with a cotton face and reverse, decorative pillow covers, and machine-washable care.
Not ideal for: Buyers who need a larger queen comforter, want cotton fill, or prefer bedding with less specific laundering instructions.
- Set size:Full/Queen, 7 pieces
- Comforter dimensions:88 x 92 inches
- Design:Reversible roses and stripe pattern
- Face and reverse:100% cotton
- Fill:100% polyester
- Included components:1 comforter, 2 standard pillowcases, 1 Euro sham, 2 throw pillow covers
- Care:Machine wash cold on gentle; tumble dry low
- Manufacturer:Revman International
Our verdict“I’d choose Mattie for a decorative, cotton-faced comforter that can be washed at home, while checking its full/queen dimensions before ordering.”

How We Picked
I compared these three Macy’s bedding options around the decisions that matter after the pattern catches your eye: construction, warmth, care, coverage, and what comes in the set. The picks are not interchangeable. One is an oversized, removable-cover comforter set built around a layered look; another is a light quilt intended to work across seasons; the third is a cotton-faced comforter set with coordinated floral accents and home-laundry instructions.
My ranking reflects the breadth of use and the size of the tradeoffs. Madison Park takes the top position because its cotton face and back, generous queen dimensions, and removable cover offer the strongest combination of materials and styling options, despite the dry-cleaning requirement. Bedford is my best lightweight pick because its reversible design and straightforward machine care make it useful for layering, although it will not satisfy someone seeking substantial warmth. Mattie earns the third spot as a more decorative, washable comforter option, but its smaller listed dimensions and more careful laundering make it less flexible than the first two for some households.
I also weighed set contents against practical value rather than counting every pillow cover equally. Madison Park has the most elaborate assortment, but its decorative pillows use mixed materials, so the set is not a uniform cotton package. Bedford keeps the contents focused on the quilt and standard shams. Mattie adds several coordinating pillow components, though buyers should note that its listed components include two standard pillowcases, one Euro sham, and two throw pillow covers. I have used the supplied product information only and do not imply hands-on testing.
| Macy’s bedding | Care |
|---|---|
| Madison Park Signature Queen C | Dry clean cover; machine wash insert |
| Laura Ashley Bedford Blue Reve | Machine washable |
| Laura Ashley Mattie Stripe Ser | Machine wash cold on gentle; tumble dry low |
Factors to Consider When Choosing Best Macy’s Bedding
I’d choose among these sets by starting with the kind of bed covering you actually want, then checking the care label and dimensions. A quilt, a conventional comforter, and a removable-cover set solve different problems, even when all are presented as coordinated bedding.
Decide between a quilt and a comforter
Bedford is a lightweight quilt, so it works especially well as a top layer over sheets and can be paired with another blanket when more warmth is needed. Madison Park and Mattie are comforter sets with polyester filling, giving them a fuller bed-covering role. I would not treat Bedford’s low weight as a flaw if layering is the plan; it becomes a drawback only when you expect one piece to supply substantial warmth. For a room that runs cool or for someone who likes a lofty look, the comforters are the stronger starting point.
Match care instructions to your household
Care can change which set makes sense more than pattern or piece count. Madison Park’s cover is dry clean only, though the insert can be machine washed. That split arrangement can work for someone who wants a removable cover and does not mind professional cleaning, but it adds a recurring task. Bedford is the simplest care choice because it is machine washable. Mattie can also be washed at home, but it calls for a gentle cold cycle and low-heat drying. If your washer is small or you prefer uncomplicated laundry, consider the weight and volume of a full set as well as the written care instructions.
Compare fabric and fill separately
A cotton surface does not mean the entire comforter is cotton. Madison Park and Mattie list 100% cotton faces and backs, but both use polyester fill. Bedford has a cotton shell and a fill blend of 80% cotton and 20% polyester. If fill composition is a deciding point, Bedford has the highest cotton share in its fill, while the comforters offer a fuller format with polyester filling. Madison Park’s description also identifies its fill as hypoallergenic polyester down alternative. I would compare the surface fabric, internal fill, and decorative pillow materials as separate details rather than assuming one material label covers the whole set.
Check dimensions against your bed
Queen labels do not make these pieces the same size. Madison Park measures 92 by 96 inches, Bedford measures 90 by 90 inches, and Mattie’s full/queen comforter measures 88 by 92 inches. The listed dimensions suggest Madison Park offers the most coverage, but mattress depth, bed frame, and desired drape still affect fit. If you want fabric to fall farther down the sides, compare the actual measurements with your mattress and existing comforter. For Mattie in particular, verify that a full/queen size gives the coverage you expect before choosing it over a dedicated queen option.
Choose set contents you will use
Madison Park has the most elaborate assortment, with standard and Euro shams plus three decorative pillows. That can help create a finished look in one purchase, but it also means more pieces to arrange, store, and care for; the decorative pillows include mixed materials. Bedford is the pared-back set, limited to the quilt and two standard shams. Mattie sits between them in styling, adding two standard pillowcases, a Euro sham, and two throw pillow covers. I’d count only components that fit your pillows and routine: extra pieces are useful when they replace items you would otherwise buy, not simply because the package contains more.
Think about reversible style and how long you want it to last
All three sets bring pattern or texture, but the look differs. Bedford’s blue toile and geometric reverse has a traditional, easy-to-layer character; Mattie’s pink roses and stripes make a more overt floral statement; Madison Park’s ivory clipped jacquard relies on texture and decorative buttons rather than a bold print. Reversibility gives Bedford and Mattie a second coordinated face, while Madison Park’s removable cover supports changing the insert or refreshing the cover separately. I’d choose the pattern that works with your existing curtains and wall colors, then weigh whether a quieter neutral or a more distinctive print will remain appealing in the room.
Frequently Asked Questions
Which of these Macy’s bedding sets is best for a queen bed?
For a queen bed where coverage is the priority, Madison Park has the largest listed comforter dimensions at 92 by 96 inches. Bedford is listed at 90 by 90 inches, while Mattie is a full/queen set with an 88-by-92-inch comforter. Mattress depth and preferred side drape still matter, so I’d compare the measurements with your current bedding before choosing. If you want a lighter layer rather than a comforter, Bedford may be the better match even though its dimensions are smaller.
Which set is easiest to care for?
Bedford has the most straightforward care listing: the quilt is machine washable. Mattie is also machine washable, but its instructions specify a cold gentle cycle and low-heat tumble drying. Madison Park separates the cover and insert: the insert can be machine washed, but the removable cover requires dry cleaning. I’d select Bedford if simple laundry is your main concern, and avoid Madison Park if you do not want a dry-clean-only bedding component.
Which option is warmest?
The descriptions position Madison Park and Mattie as comforter sets with polyester fill, while Bedford is explicitly a lightweight quilt designed for layering. No warmth rating is provided for the comforters, so I would not claim a precise warmth level from the specifications alone. If you want a lighter bed covering, Bedford is the clearest fit; if you prefer a fuller comforter format, compare Madison Park and Mattie, then factor in room temperature and any blankets you plan to use.
Are the included shams and pillow covers interchangeable?
Not necessarily. Madison Park includes two standard shams, two Euro shams, and three decorative pillows; Bedford includes two standard shams; Mattie includes two standard pillowcases, one Euro sham, and two throw pillow covers. Pillowcases, shams, and decorative covers have different purposes and dimensions, so check the listed sizes against your pillows. The product descriptions also identify mixed materials among Madison Park’s decorative pillow covers, which may matter if you want a consistent fabric feel.
Which set should I choose if I prefer cotton bedding?
Each set has cotton in its construction, but the details differ. Madison Park and Mattie have 100% cotton comforter faces and backs, with polyester fill. Bedford has a 100% cotton shell and an 80% cotton, 20% polyester fill. If you specifically want cotton in the fill as well as the outer fabric, Bedford is the closest match; if you prefer a comforter with a cotton surface, Madison Park and Mattie fit that preference, though neither has an all-cotton fill.
Conclusion
My recommendation depends on which compromise you are most willing to make. Choose Madison Park Signature if you want the most generous listed queen coverage, a textured ivory look, and a set packed with shams and decorative pillows—and are comfortable dry cleaning the cover. Choose Laura Ashley Bedford if you want a lightweight, reversible quilt that is easy to machine wash and plan to layer it for warmth. Choose Laura Ashley Mattie if your priority is a cotton-faced, floral comforter with coordinated accents and home laundering, after checking that its full/queen dimensions suit your bed. Across these Macy’s bedding options, the best fit comes down to warmth, care routine, coverage, and whether you will actually use the extra pieces.






